A New Study Challenges The Hospital Practice Of Limiting Elderly Patient Activity To Prevent Falls
November 7, 2011
In 2008, as part of a larger initiative aimed at reducing preventable hospital errors and lowering costs, Medicare stopped reimbursing for the treatment of injuries related to in-hospital falls. Geriatricians were quick to point out that could have an unintended and extremely negative consequence: In trying to keep elderly patients from falling, it was possible that hospitals might discourage patients from moving about at all. And for the elderly, even a few days of immobility can produce what's called hospital-associated deconditioning—a loss of muscle mass, aerobic capacity and sense of balance that reduces a patient's ability to function after he or she is discharged from the hospital.
While theoretically it might seem that elderly patients who move around more would be more likely to fall, a new study from University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston researchers suggests otherwise. Analyzing the mobility patterns of elderly patients fitted with small electronic devices that counted every step they took, the scientists determined that patients who suffered in-hospital falls actually moved around no more than patients who did not fall.
"We matched 10 patients who had fallen with 25 who had not fallen based on age, gender, reason for admission, illness severity, and mobility status before admission," said UTMB assistant professor Steven Fisher, lead author of a paper on the study now online in Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. "All of these people had worn step activity monitors during their stay in the hospital, and when we analyzed the data from these devices we found no statistical difference in the amount of walking between the groups."
According to Fisher, the study's results suggest reducing elderly patients' mobility doesn't just risk hospital deconditioning—it also may do little toward the prevention of falls. "Hospital falls are a complex issue, with a number of factors at work," Fisher said. "In our study, for example, we found that cognition was a big factor—patients suffering from delirium were more likely to fall." In addition, Fisher pointed to the hospital environment as a potential contributor to falls. All of the falls noted in the study took place at night, and 60 percent of them were related to visits to the bathroom. It is likely not possible to eliminate older patient falls altogether, Fisher observed. "Evidence is accumulating, however, that even small amounts of activity can be beneficial in this context," he said. "What we see from this study is that getting that benefit doesn't necessarily mean increasing the risk of falling."
If a loved one is hospitalized, talk to the medical team about weighing the benefits and risks of activity and what steps can be taken to prevent muscle loss.
Stay connected with Parentgiving.
New subscribers will save 10% on your first order!*
*New subscribers only. This coupon cannot be combined with other offers, used on Dry Direct
orders or used on eWheels, Golden Technologies, Pride Mobility or Joerns products. Maximum savings of $75. Some restrictions